Comparing Cats and Tris
There's a well bantered saying that for trimarans you have to build five hulls, for cats only two. Trimarans require more time on the structure but usually have less detail in the interior fit-out. There’s only one hull with livable spaces and certainly a lot less interior surfaces to finish. Accordingly we can assume the total build time is similar for cats and tris and other factors come into play rather than the number of hulls.
In choosing a design you might also argue that a for a given level of performance you can build a significantly smaller trimaran. That argument probably wont wash well with a family setting out on a world cruise with a bunch of water toys and a galley that would be the envy of most restaurant owners.
In one respect trimarans are easier to build than cats. Everything is at a suitable working height for most of the project and the beams and floats can be easily moved around the factory space. A cat calls for a lot climbing once you’re working at wing deck height. Aside from the comments above a trimaran optimized for racing with a very spartan interior could come in well under the build time of a similar sized cruising cat.
The Factors at Play
Putting the catamaran or trimaran issue aside, build time varies between different projects for a number of reasons. Preparation, organization, and experience are significant factors. Other factors include build method and level of technology, level of skill and quality of finish required, extent of fit-out and equipment, the tools and equipment you have at hand, how much work you subcontract out, and the building information provided by your designer.
All of these factors have real effects.
I've written a quite a bit about the need for planning, management and coordination in boat building and will continue to do so. Successful boat builders are organised boat builders and they build good reputations based on that organization. If you're building in your back yard with a bit of help from your friends on the weekends the issues mentioned above are probably not big issues. If you've rented factory space and have workers on the payroll then these are all real world issues.
The graph shows estimated hours for a one off catamaran or trimaran. If your project is fairly typical it will sit somewhere close to the dark curve. It you're an experienced builder and your project is not overly complex it might sit in the blue area below the line. If it is complex, if it requires an exceptional finish inside and out it will sit above the line.
TIME SAVING WITH CNC PANELS
Using flat panels can significantly reduce build time, possibly by around 20%, maybe even more.
One designer claims his 38’ LOA cat can be built from a DuFlex kit in 4000 hours. This may well be the case, but I expect it applies to a well planned project using experienced workers and maybe a fairly basic fit-out.
For a 40’ cat using a kit I would generally expect more like 6000 to 7000 hours. Without a kit and using more conventional methods probably more like 8000 hours.
To give some idea of the variability that’s possible, a well organized and experienced professional builder might complete a one off 60’ cat to a high standard in about 16000 hours. In contrast it is common for a large professional yard using female moulds and infused laminates to estimate between 45,000 and 50,000 hours for a similar boat.
Part of the difference could be in the amount of detailed finish work, possibly including clear carbon finish for the boat with the longer hours. It could also be in the extent of fit-out and equipment. Part of the difference could be due to a different work ethic in different countries.
I'm referring to the pace at which the work proceeds but not suggesting that faster is necessarily better and certainly not suggesting that quality is compromised in countries where the pay rates are lower.
In the country where I live an experienced boat builder is paid less than 10% of a typical hourly rate paid to a boat builder in the country I was born in. There are countries in Asia where typical wages for boat builders are a fraction again of that 10% figure. But it generally takes longer to get stuff done.
Left; This CNC DuFlex bulkhead panel achieves two things. Firstly it delivers a panel made under controlled conditions with a high fibre content, an even peel ply finish, and cut exactly to the required shape.
Secondly the panel, along with other bulkheads (and possibly some temporary frames if needed), creates a framework for the assembly of the side panels and decks, thereby achieving a composite structure built with high quality laminates without the cost of building female tooling needed for the infusion process.
Right; DuFlex panels being bonded in ATL's heat press.
The glue join cures in about ten minutes, the panels are slid forward to the next join and the individual parts are cut out of the panel assembly with a jig saw, then stack ready to be assembled to the boat. If the parts are not to be used immediately they may be left attached to the panel until needed.
Below; There was a time when the designer would have given the builder a table of offsets and the builder would have painstakingly lofted the boat and all its parts full size on the workshop floor before transferring the definitions to patterns and then the actual parts.
Today the parts get made directly from the designer's cutting files. Does that mean boat get built a lot more quickly these days? See Designer's Footnote at the end of the article.
Apart from whether a kit is being used, one of the biggest variables is in the quality of the finish, both inside and out. Yes, we all want a nicely finished boat but if you're not building from female tooling at least some amount of fairing is unavoidable. A DuFlex kit and other panel building methods will substantially reduce fairing time but it will still require a certain amount of filling and sanding both inside and out.
This is what your boat looks like possibly just a few days after your kit has been delivered. Composite parts stacked against the wall ready to be separated and assembled.
This catamaran topside panel was taped up, prep'd and and painted on the inside prior to being fitted to the boat. The unpainted areas have been left to allow for bonding to the bulkhead and floor panels. This is a major step forward in minimizing interior finish time.
Below: The level of finish of this Barefoot 40 catamaran is quite exceptional, even in places that are unlikely ever to see a human gaze. Apart from the fact that it's a boat it wouldn't be surprising to see it roll off the assembly line in the Ferrari factory in Maranello
Professional fairing and painting teams are on hand wherever boats are focused and if it's within your budget to hire one of them it can save you lot of build time.
Interior of Chincogan 52 Soul tastefully finished with judicious use of timber laminate and trim.
The hulls were female moulded and required no exterior finish work, but the interior was hand faired and painted at the expenditure of a significant portion of the total build time.
What I really like about this interior is that there is no more storage space than what is absolutely needed, providing a spacious uncluttered feel.
•Finishing composite surfaces is a big deal. Look at ways to minimize fairing time. Use pre-laminated panels that require a minimum of fairing work.
•Plan the project so you can do as much work as possible at working height on the workshop floor. Keep the workshop clean, tidy and organized.
•Employ professional teams for fairing and painting. They know how to get a better finish in less time and waste less material in the process.
•Keep the laminating work fair and tidy from day one so a minimum of finishing is required.
•Use third party components wherever possible. Longerons, Daggerboards, Rudders, Forebeam etc.
• If you have complex electrical and plumbing requirements work with your technical guys to plan ahead. Draw up schematics, place conduits where they need to run pipes and cables.
•Plan in advance with your suppliers and technicians, especially the rigger and the sail maker so you know where everything needs to go before you get to it.
• Consider having the interior, especially the saloon made by your local cabinet shop. Your designer can provide them with accurate plans and cutting files once you've determined the layout. Most cabinet makers are happy to work with modern boat building materials.
•Set up a white board in the workshop and draw up a timeline of everything that's going to happen, who is going to be involved, and what materials and equipment you are going to need.
A friend of mine who used to build boats in Australia and now builds the same boats in Asia.
I asked him how much the build hours had changed.
He told me he now doubles the allowance for build hours.
When I asked him why this is the case he thought for a few moments and then told me that in the early days of the business he was mostly full time on the shop floor working side by side with the other workers.
This was a significant motivating factor and almost certainly helped with forward planning as well.
The point is that factors that affect build hours are not always the obvious ones.
I sometimes reflect on the fact that we spend so much more time on the design work now than we did thirty years ago. Not just a bit more - but a very significant multiple of hours. That's in spite of the fact that we were working then with tech pens that used to clog up and sometimes bleed onto the mylar film which then required the ink blotches to be scratched off with a scalpel blade. Pocket calculators were cool technology.
You couldn't grab a text block and resize it, or move it to another drawing. You couldn't correct a typo with a click of the mouse. It was a delicate operation of scratching and patching. You couldn't copy a reinforcement detail from another boat and paste it into the drawing. You couldn't send a drawing to a builder by loading it to a Drop Box folder. You had to drive into town, get it printed, go to the post office, roll it up into a tube and send it off.
Yet it all seemed to go so much more quickly.
I think a similar thing may have happened with boat building. We have wet-out machines wonderful CNC facilities, and an array of other digital devices. No more full size lofting on the workshop floor and all of those complicated shapes needed for the building forms or the various composite components get delivered on the back of a truck ready to assemble.
No doubt assembly lines have greatly reduced build times for boats that are built in significant numbers, but for one off's I'm not sure that we've reduced building hours by any significant factor, if at all. I think we expect more features, finer details, more sophisticated systems and a higher standard of finish than ever before.
With our design work we go into much more detail, we look at a much wider range of possibilities, we provide services like formatting cutting files for kits, we analyze things much more deeply than ever before.
In fact the way we design boats these days, by building comprehensive digital models that include rope paths and deck hardware - it would be possible to have a boat completely manufactured and fitted using robotics.
I see one robot picking the turning block from the shelf and another bolting it to the deck while yet another applies the antifoul. Or maybe it's just one robot with multifunctional arms?
………………………Just a thought!
The combined Newsletter for Grainger Designs and Rocket Factory Trimarans
Our DuFLEX kit systems streamline the construction process for amateurs and professional yards alike. More details here…